Pizza Archives - Freddie and Pepper's

$2
Whole Wheat Crust
- Med - $2
- Large - $2
$3/$4
Sundried Tomatoes
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$4/$5
Plant Based Vegan Cheese (Daiya)
- Med - $4
- Large - $5
$4/$5
Shrimp
- Med - $4
- Large - $5
$3/$4
Ricotta
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$4.5/$5
Prosciutto
- Med - $4.5
- Large - $5
$2.50/$3
Pineapple
- Med - $2.50
- Large - $3
$2.50/$3
Olives (Black)
- Med - $2.50
- Large - $3
$3.50/$4
Meatballs
- Med - $3.50
- Large - $4
$2.50/$3
Jalapeño
- Med - $2.50
- Large - $3
$3/$4
Ham
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$3/$4
Goat Cheese
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$2.5/$3
Anchovies
- Med - $2.5
- Large - $3
$3/$4
Fresh Mozzarella
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$3/$4
Tomatoes (Fresh)
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$3/$4
Eggplant
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$3/$4
Basil
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$4/$5
Chicken
- Med - $4
- Large - $5
$4/$5
Bacon
- Med - $4
- Large - $5
$3/$4
Baby Clams
- Med - $3
- Large - $4
$4/$5
Avocado
- Med - $4
- Large - $5
$3/$3.50
Artichokes
- Med - $3
- Large - $3.50

Freddie & Pepper's

4.0

Based on 519 Reviews

Julia R.

2023-03-20 12:07:36

If you want some good NYC pizza come here. It may look like a hole in the wall but the pizza is great. Staff is super friendly & it seemed like they have... read more

Mark M.

2023-03-14 04:22:18

A really good slice of cheese pizza with excellent flavor. The staff here need to be a bit more friendlier. When I went in they had lots of slices on... read more

Luci L.

2023-03-03 11:07:53

The pizza here is really good, and hit the spot when I arrived in NYC after a long flight. The second night, I ordered two slices instead of one, which made... read more

Cyndi R.

2022-12-03 15:22:59

Great NY style pizza. Worth every penny and the people Are friendly. Very easy on the wallet and great service read more

Asa L.

2022-08-14 11:50:56

OVERALL: -Chicken parm sandwich really hit the spot. -I'm giving three stars because the sandwich was only ok and I'm pretty sure I was overcharged. -I... read more

Francisco D.

2022-07-08 07:52:30

Super hidden and a pretty small hole in the wall place, but honestly really, really great pizza. The guys who work there are friendly and effective. I... read more

Cathrin G.

2022-05-29 08:52:49

BEST PIZZA IN NYC!!! Seriously. I grew up on tri-state area and lived in Brooklyn and had many many pizzas throughout NJ & NY. Freddie & Peppers is PERFECT.... read more

Jeff G.

2022-05-24 04:41:08

This was one of the places that made me wish we could do half stars. It was more of a 3.5 star meal for me but I don't think it's fair to drop them to a... read more

Juliette M.

2022-05-20 16:24:48

Delicious New York style pizza if you're on the go or just trying to have a casual bite. We tried 6 different kinds of pizza and all were super delicious.... read more

Jean T.

2022-04-30 10:08:09

Indoor seating is back! I keep meaning to try the Chilean empanadas, and maybe I will, some day, but I REALLY love NY pizza, and it just isn't the same in... read more

Kit Michele G.

2022-04-24 12:00:38

Finally got to try this spot! Tried the Buffalo Chicken pizza slice which was pretty good but not exactly the best slice I've ever had. Also don't know if... read more

Lydia S.

2022-04-02 20:59:00

This was the crunchiest slice of pizza I've had in the best way and it was very thin. The cheese had a lot of flavor but there wasn't enough sauce, so I... read more

Hannah M.

2022-03-28 21:48:05

Pretty average pizza shop - they sell slices, whole pies, pasta dishes, Hero's, and randomly empanadas and beef patties? Not sure where that's coming from,... read more

Geoff G.

2020-02-02 14:14:15

Great NY pizza. Crispy crust and tasty slices. Based on the celebrity photos on the walls, looks like it's a popular local eatery. When you walk in... read more

Steven H.

2019-11-18 13:10:45

Swinged by this place on my last day in the city. Just around the corner from the original Levain bakery- Freddie & Peppers is effing delicious. Location... read more

Ben G.

2019-10-27 20:27:34

The best pizza on the UWS! Until someone can tell me a better plain slice to try, I'm sticking with this claim. It's a super nondescript spot, down a flight... read more

Pizza

Regular Pizza-Plain

Gourmet Toppings

Whole Wheat Crust

Sundried Tomatoes

Plant Based Vegan Cheese (Daiya)

Shrimp

Ricotta

Prosciutto

Pineapple

Olives (Black)

Meatballs

Jalapeño

Ham

Goat Cheese

Anchovies

Fresh Mozzarella

Tomatoes (Fresh)

Eggplant

Basil

Chicken

Bacon

Baby Clams

Avocado

Artichokes

Toppings

Everything

Sausage

Pepperoni

Onions

Green Peppers

Mushrooms (Fresh)

Extra Cheese

Garlic